In an attempt to increase the transparency of efforts to enforce U.N.Instit Resolution 1874 provisions relating to the interdiction of vessels, and their chances of success, Nautilus ute Senior Associate Mark Valencia has suggested that a U.N. force of some kind be created to establish the validity of and conduct such interdictions.
U.N. Resolution 1874, paragraph 11 “Calls upon all States to inspect, in accordance with their national authorities and legislation, and consistent with international law, all cargo to and from the DPRK, in their territory, including seaports and airports, if the State concerned has information that provides reasonable grounds to believe the cargo contains items the supply, sale, transfer, or export of which is prohibited.”
Valencia suggests in his June 16th Nautilus Institute report, “UNSC Anti-North Korea Resolution a Recipe for Conflict?” that a number of vessels flying the U.N. flag could act “on behalf of a UN organization (perhaps an enhanced sanctions committee or a group of ‘experts’) that would assess intelligence, co-ordinate and fund activities, and make recommendations or decisions regarding specific or generic interdictions.”
This, Valencia asserts, “could eliminate double standards, increase transparency and answer key questions such as what combinations of actors and materials represent threats and what are ‘reasonable grounds’ for interdiction,” and “would also help avoid erroneous judgments and disagreements that might impede legitimate commerce, delay action or increase tensions.”
Among the most important results of such a system would be that it would avoid putting any single state into direct conflict with North Korea, which has already stated that it will view any attempt to inspect its vessels as “an act of war.”
In any case, the importance of the provision enabling interdiction of vessels is largely dependent on the likelihood of North Korea using its relatively small shipping capacity to transport illicit cargo. With Resolution 1874 extending the ban on weapons imports and exports to everything “except small arms and light weapons and their related materiel,” the range of items which are now prohibited has risen, and thus so has the likelihood of any given cargo containing prohibited items, but some experts are doubtful.
In a February, 2009 report for the East-West Center, Professor Hazel Smith asserted that North Korea is unlikely to use its own ships to transport weapons or components, though she conceded that they might use ships flagged in other states which would also be covered under Resolution 1874, while former U.N. Ambassador John Bolton has consistently asserted that most North Korean shipments of weapons or components travel overland or by air, and while cargo inspections at airports are also covered by Resolution 1874, there is no explanation of how they might be achieved.









