According to one leading academic, the potential expense of modernizing the North Korean economy is not being seriously examined by those who will face paying the bill for it, and it should be, for North Korea is weaker than many people think.

Such is the view of Stanford University research fellow Peter Beck. Writing in the Wall Street Journal on Sunday, he outlined the three basic scenarios for reunification, categorized as smooth, somewhat like Germany, extremely rough like Vietnam, or messy like Romania and Albania, but made the critically important point that from an economic perspective there is actually no great difference between them. All will be inordinately expensive, and not enough people are taking that fact seriously.

North Korea is, Beck asserts, in a mess incomparable with East Germany, a country of relatively few people with, by Communist bloc standards, decent incomes. The North Korean people are far poorer and, upon reunification, the North Korean infrastructure would need a near-complete overhaul; the electrical grid, the roads, the railways, the airports, the ports. This could, various assessments suggest, cost anywhere from $50 billion at the low end to $1.5 trillion, while Beck himself suggests that a more ambitious aim, raising average North Korean incomes to 80% of the South Korean average, rather than the 60% target used by many, could cost anywhere from $2 to $5 trillion. Putting that in more manageable terms, it represents at least $40,000 for every man, woman and child in the South.

Yet, Beck notes, this is not being seriously considered by regional powers or multilateral lenders, and to date only colonial reparations from Japan are to any extent guaranteed in the event of reunification. In any case, even such reparations, coupled to current levels of Chinese aid and trade, represent a drop in the proverbial ocean of the $67 billion Beck says would be needed annually over the 30 years following reunification.

In conclusion, Beck warns, “Building a modern economy in North Korea would be a wise investment in peace and prosperity in North Asia.” In essence, such spending is not a choice, it is an inevitability, so, “Policy makers need to think about where that money will come from and how it should be spent to minimize the risk of wasting it in post-reunification confusion.”

Chris Green, Leiden University
Christopher Green is a researcher in Korean Studies based at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Chris has published widely on North Korean political messaging strategies, contemporary South Korean broadcast media, and the socio-politics of Korean peninsula migration. He is the former Manager of International Affairs for Daily NK. His X handle is: @Dest_Pyongyang.