Speaking at the final session of the two-day ASAN North Korea Conference 2011, two international experts have cautioned against excessive faith in the power of technology to inspire change in North Korea, but also offered some modest causes for optimism.

Pessimism stems from the fact, according to Evgeny Morozov of Stanford University, that if any dictatorial state is “smart, willing and technologically savvy enough,” it can control technology including the internet, and that even if the internet were introduced in North Korea, the public and politicians should not assume that the relatively free access to information that it could engender would lead to wholly positive outcomes.

There would be the possibility that they could introduce technology that would allow for surveillance, censorship and even propaganda to their own advantage, he explained, something which is also being done for the existing cellphone network.

Ways of utilizing internet technology for the benefit of the authorities could include data mining to track people who might be planning to express discontent in more public ways, something done to great effect in China, or introducing paid bloggers to work in unofficial forums to try and guide discussion and quietly promote official positions and propaganda, as is done to great effect in both Russia and Iran.

In summary, Morozov said that he sees no technological or other real problem for the North Korean government in introducing the internet more widely in the country, provided that the following conditions are met; ▲ a rapid and effective ‘kill switch’ that can shut down the internet in certain regions at certain times; and ▲ sufficiently effective monitoring equipment imported from China or elsewhere.

If the authorities are smart, Morozov continued, they will also preemptively introduce indigenous programs to replicate the function of things like Twitter and Facebook in order to maintain greater control over the data they contain, something done to tremendous effect in both Vietnam and China.

Despite this, Andrei Lankov said he sees North Korea’s problems as more endemic and less malleable than Morozov, noting that images of South Korean prosperity are hard to censor completely, and since he believes such images are among the most poisonous of all things to North Korea’s social cohesion, they will not reform.

Had the North Korean state not been as repressive as it has to date, Lankov asserted, it would not have survived this long, and in future, “If North Korean people are exposed to pictures of South Korean prosperity, they will begin to entertain grave doubts about the right of the leaders to run the country.”

Nevertheless, although he doesn’t see the internet as a likely way forward in North Korea, Lankov did point to some very positive developments, including the porous Sino-North Korean border, DVDs spread by the “invisible hand of the market” which can be played on DVD players that, due to their legality, he believes have penetrated 60-70% of homes, and quality South Korean products which tell their own story of South Korea’s technological superiority.

These things won’t bring change tomorrow, all the experts agreed, but they portend future pressure.

Chris Green, Leiden University
Christopher Green is a researcher in Korean Studies based at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Chris has published widely on North Korean political messaging strategies, contemporary South Korean broadcast media, and the socio-politics of Korean peninsula migration. He is the former Manager of International Affairs for Daily NK. His X handle is: @Dest_Pyongyang.