Yesterday’s publication of Kim Jong Il and then-President Roh Moo Hyun’s October 2007 inter-Korean summit transcript has incited angry political conflict in South Korea. However, there are additional concerns over what effect the publication could have on inter-Korean relations.

There is every possibility that the North Korean authorities will publicly denounce the decision to publish the transcript, calling it an act that undermines inter-Korean trust. However, it truth the transcript does not contain anything disadvantageous to North Korea, and, since it pertains to a different era in inter-Korean contacts, is unlikely to play a major role.

Experts also point out that North Korea has become infamous down the years for publicizing the existence of nominally secret talks with South Korea and others, meaning that there would be little persuasive logic to an angry response now.

Yoo Dong Yeol of the Police Science Institute explained, “The publication of the transcript could be used as a negative factor in South-North relations, but the publication is not enough by itself to put relations into spasm. The primary cause of frozen South-North relations is North Korea’s hostile strategy; the publication of the transcript will not make things any worse.”

A second expert, Oh Gyeong Seob of the Sejong Institute, agreed, saying, “Such a publication could have been a problematic issue if South-North dialogue had been going well and relations had been good, but at a time like this it is hard to see it having a direct effect. If both sides agree that dialogue is needed then talks can begin; it won’t be a major factor.”

However, Oh did warn that “to North Korea, this publication of the transcript offers an aspect that can be used in future political campaigns, as ‘an act that undermines trust’ and as a tool to incite ‘South-South conflict.’”