The proposed merger between the New Progressive Party and Democratic Labor Party has finally been scuttled after the NPP rejected it at a party meeting in Seoul yesterday. Needing a two thirds majority, just 222 of the 410 members present at the meeting voted in favor of the proposed merger.

The biggest issue for some was that of the presence of the People’s Participation Party, which lays claim to the legacy of former President Roh Moo Hyun, in the proposed merge. Attempting to assuage fears, NPP chair Cho Seung Soo alluded to the concerns of the party faithful in his opening address, stressing, “We are not seeking a merger with the People’s Participation Party, but a coalition.”

However, despite Cho’s pleas, members’ minds were apparently already made up. On top of the PPP issue, differences of opinion over how to handle North Korea as well as members’ distrust of the DLP also appeared to play a part in the decision making.

A source from the New Progressive Party explained to The Daily NK, “The presence of the PPP was the really contentious issue, and that’s why the leadership had to plead with the members,” adding, “The atmosphere suggested that dispute over the PPP’s involvement would not have ended following any union.”

“Their obeisance to the Kim Jong Il regime is not something we could agree with,” the source went on, citing also, “The lack of a clear policy on North Korea as well as their undemocratic and imperious operational style prior to the split,” referring to the NPP’s original shape as a splinter group of the DLP.

NPP leader Cho and two of his senior advisers, Noh Hee Chan and Shim Sang Jeong, appeared to accept the result and left the conference hall. Other members reacted without fanfare or applause.

Nothing is known for sure about the NPP’s future now that the merger proposal has been defeated, but it is the future of the DLP that will attract the most attention.

The DLP has two options going forward. One would be to hold a party meeting and push for a merger with the People’s Participation Party. In this case though, the DLP would still face the burden of a two-thirds majority to pass the motion, limiting its chances of success.

The other option is for the DLP to create a new party. It is believed that the DLP had already considered this course of action prior to the NPP vote falling through.