[imText1]It is no longer taboo anywhere to talk about the North Korean succession. As Chuck Downs of the US Committee for North Korean Human Rights pointed out on Friday morning, even North Koreans are allowed to mention it now.
And so, the 2009 International Conference on North Korean Human Rights concluded on Friday afternoon with that key topic, “The Post-Kim Jong Il Era and Korea’s Future.” Everyone agreed it was a timely debate, for as the Heritage Foundation’s Bruce Klingner pointed out right at from the start, not only is Kim Jong Il sick, but last year’s stroke “could just as easily have been fatal.”
Furthermore, with regards to Kim Jong Woon, “a copy of a copy is never as good as the original,” as Klingner put it, while any other collective regime would face the additional problem of lacking the legitimacy of its predecessor.
So the risk of collapse is growing, and the panelists agree there is much work to do.
The timing of any intervention vis a vis its legitimacy is a key point. The Bosnian conflict of the 1990s may have changed the meaning of sovereignty, according to Korea Institute of Defense Analysis researcher Baek Seung Joo, but without complete and incontrovertible collapse, the international community can’t undertake intervention in North Korea as and when it wishes. North Korea has to request it, or it has to be clear that the security of a surrounding state is at risk.
Equally importantly, as Choo Yong Shik, the Deputy-Chairman of the US-Korea Institute at SAIS, explained, South Korea cannot rely on its military alone to deal with an emergency situation, and therefore a good dialogue with the U.S. is essential, since it is they who would be likely to be a key source of funds and military assistance if North Korea collapsed into a “failed state,” and with China, whose own territorial interests in the area could easily bring them into conflict with other regional powers.
Not only that, Yoon Duk Min, a professor at IFANS pointed out, but in a reunification situation, the U.S. would be providing security to surrounding countries who feel uncomfortable about a reunified Korea, just as the U.S. did at the time of German reunification, meaning that continuing US involvement is important regardless of anti-American sentiment among certain sectors of society in the countries of the region.
However, Baek pointed out in his presentation, above all, although North and South Korea are legally two different countries with legally two different peoples, South Korea should be able to take the leading role, and as Lee Sang Hyun, the Director of Security Studies Program at the Sejong Institute added, coordination is urgently needed.
Either way, whoever takes the lead, Baek put his stress on a good point, “The collapse has already started… there are already 15,000 North Korean defectors living in South Korea,” and so, “We have to start preparations, and we should come up with more detailed policies.”
Yoon agreed, “Even if the risk of collapse is less than 10%, we have to prepare for it.”










