In an unexpected move, China recently permitted safe passage to South Korea for a group of defectors who had been living in the Republic of Korea Consulate-General in Beijing for three years.

However, while widely welcomed, the move does not appear to signal a complete change of heart on the part of the Chinese government, which still regards North Koreans as illegal economic migrants and deports those it is able to apprehend accordingly. As such, calls for China to alter its policy on defectors more generally remain.

In reality, even if the choice to release the group were taken by Beijing partly as a result of international pressure surrounding the forced repatriation of defectors issue, and it is not clear that it was, that is still a long way from saying that overall policy can be changed by a diet of ‘more of the same’.

Instead, experts say that there is the need for an improved diplomatic strategy from Seoul, to generate more pressure through international public opinion and from there to resolve defector issues more broadly.

“The Chinese government’s measure came from the efforts of private citizens and government diplomacy,” Yoon Yeo Sang, who heads up the Seoul-based NGO Database Center for North Korean Human Rights, explained. “In future, if China does not accept the movement of defectors to South Korea then we must use a two-track strategy with the Chinese government, operating in tandem with the efforts of the international community and private citizens.”

“We must continually let the Chinese government know that if defectors are repatriated they will face punishment and oppression,” Yoon continued. “In this way, China can be made to demand of North Korea that defectors be safe; this is one way in which their defector policy could be changed.”

Elsewhere, there are also questions being raised over the way the media, in particular in South Korea, has been dealing with defector issues in recent months. By overly publicizing the situation on the ground in China, it is alleged that the Chinese government’s range of actions is being constrained, and it is thus becoming harder for Beijing to allow defectors onward movement to South Korea.

A government source explained the point yesterday, saying, “There is an element of international public opinion involved in the latest Chinese move, but above all they acquiesced to the transit of the defectors out of consideration for the South Korean government. If the domestic media reports arrivals like they did today, then China, which does stress its relations with North Korea, may not be able to acquiesce to the departure of more defectors.”