A South Korean research group has called for support for economic and political engagement with North Korea in order to bring about modernization and, thereafter, democracy. On the other hand, others have suggested that the North Korean regime is economically so incompetent that such a model has little chance of success.
Presenting the findings of the North Korea Modernization Research Group to an International Donor Conference this morning, Institute for Far Eastern Studies researcher Philip Park said his group believes that, in the absence of regime change, the South Korean model of state-led development is the only realistic option for dragging North Korea into the modern age.
Park asserts that because Seoul was following a strategy of increasing exports during the 1960s and 70s, the regime of former President Park Chung Hee was obliged to observe international law and protocol to an increasingly high standard. Pointing to the Kaesong Industrial Complex as an example, Park says that a similar transition can be encouraged in North Korea as well.
At the same time, the people of South Korea, who needed to be well-educated in order to modernize the economy as the chosen development strategy demanded, began to ask for more and better human rights. This, Park suggested, is an almost inevitable trend under similar circumstances, pointing for guidance to the way South Korea, Singapore and Taiwan all followed the same economic and political trajectory.
Therefore, Park concludes, to achieve North Korean modernization, the international community first needs to guarantee North Korea’s regime security before following a 7-part assistance program which includes improving North Korea’s capacity to trade and institutionalizing both the market within North Korea and international standards of financial transparency.
However, another speaker, the Venerable Pomnyun, Chairman of the Peace Foundation, was swift to call into question the applicability of the South Korean model to the North Korean situation.
Most people agree that South Korea under President Park Chung Hee was, though repressive and dictatorial, dedicated to economic growth and development. As IFES researcher Park said, democracy may not have been the aim, but it is what resulted anyway. However, North Korea is different, and “not very capable of making sound judgments or predicting their economic future,” Ven. Pomnyun asserted.
Therefore, he went on, the “ultimate goal should be a legitimate market” and a “law that ensures human rights,” rather than the launching of a development model led by the state.
Another speaker, Park Hyeong Jung of the Korea Institute for National Unification, agreed, saying that in the current circumstances reform is unlikely. “In order for meaningful changes to take place,” Park stated, “political forces with enough will and ability to reform must arise. However, with all factors considered, it is unlikely that such power will emerge anytime soon.”









