The controversy over the authenticity of former President Roh Moo Hyun’s alleged remarks about the “abandonment” of the West Sea Northern Limit Line is getting ever more intense.
In recent days, Democratic United Party presidential candidate Moon Jae In has said that a joint fishing zone in the region, as proposed by the Roh administration, is the best way to keep the peace, while the DUP floor leader in the National Assembly, Park Jie Won, told a recent radio broadcast that the “NLL is not a true territorial boundary.”
However, unification and security experts spoken to by Daily NK have pointed out that the DUP lawmakers are running the risk of entangling themselves in a 40-year old North Korean NLL strategy. The idea of a joint fishing zone is, they say, implausible.
▲ Very risky in terms of security
An anonymous research fellow from a South Korean policy research institute told Daily NK, “The NLL, which was set in place so as to keep the peace, is being violated by North Korea in order to invalidate it, and if we establish a joint fishing zone there then that will create an excellent environment in which to do exactly that.”
North Korea has been attempting to render the NLL invalid for a number of years. The first and second Yeonpyeong sea battles in 1999 and 2002, the Cheonan sinking and Yeonpyeong Island were all strategic maneuvers for the same purpose. If the NLL becomes the site of a joint fishing zone, it provides both a new way for North Korea to provoke the South and a new route by which to penetrate deep into South Korean territory.
Former ROK Navy Operations Commander Kim Sung Nam expressed his concerns, saying, “North Korea says that it wants to establish a joint fishing zone as a way to create a place of reconciliation and cooperation, but its real purpose is not that, it is to attack the 5 West Sea Islands. We would be getting ourselves into a lot of trouble if we set up a joint fishing zone, because our intentions do not match North Korea’s.”
However, a spokesperson for the Moon camp, Jin Sung Jun dismissed the issues raised, asserting, “On the contrary, setting up a joint fishing zone is like North Korea recognizing the NLL. Some people are saying it is a security threat, but quite the opposite; the threat will disappear.”
▲ NLL: a boundary recognized by North Korea
Under the Korean War armistice agreement, the DMZ formed the inter-Korean land border and the NLL formed the coastal boundary. There have since been many cases in which North Korea has recognized the existing boundary.
For example, Saenuri Party lawmaker Shim Yoon Jo recently pointed out that North Korea: ▲ agreed that the NLL could act as an inter-Korean contact point in 1984 when it accepted flood aid; and ▲ agreed to accept it as an air traffic control boundary during a 1996 International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) meeting.
Researcher Oh Gyeong Sub of the Sejong Institute agreed, placing the blame on past left wing administrations. “North Korea has acknowledged the NLL as the military demarcation line, and it was reconfirmed in the Inter-Korean Basic Agreement of 1991,” he explained. “However, seeing that the Kim Dae Jung-Roh Moo Hyun administrations were willing to give them another chance, North Korea caused a bigger dispute thinking that it could derive bigger concessions from North Korea.”
According to Oh, if Moon wants to back his claim of a ‘joint fishing zone’ he will need to make it clear in advance that: ▲ South Korea sees the NLL as delineating its territory and will safeguard it as such; and ▲ that doubts over comments made by former President Roh are completely unfounded.










