[imText1]Minister of Unification Chung Dong-Young, in his attendance of Unification, Foreign Affairs & Trade Committee of the National Assembly, said he has gave “a important suggestoin” to Kim Jong Il in June 17, and then explained his suggestion to the US.
In answer to governor Kwon Young Gil’s question, “I have suggested the “important suggestoin” to Commander Kim first and explained in to the US.
According to Minister Chung’s explanation, after a week of inter-Korean summit, South Korea gave a suggestion to North Korea without first agreeing with the US.
Minister Chung said, “this was an act to no further delay the issue of nuclear but to resolve it in an epochal way.” Although the content of the “important suggestoin” was not revealed, it is not difficult to guess that it contains some unusual suggestions which surpasses the level of the six-party talks.
First Make a Suggestion to North Korea and Late Notify to the US
In the press conference for the ROK-US summit, President Bush said what US suggested at the third six-party talks is still valid and that it is North Korea’s turn to respond. This means that the US was unaware of South Korea’s important suggestoin until then.
In other words, the government of South Korea was holding the hand of its ally yet was making a secret deal behind the scene. Furthermore, it is considered as a serious “crossing over the line” for South Korea to suggest North Korea to resolve the nuclear issue without consulting to the other negotiation parties.
President Roh said, “(between ROK-US) basic principles are perfectly agreed upon the North Korean nuclear problem and we are also consistently dealing with the various problem occurring in the process of negotiation.”
The basic principle here includes the process of responding to the North Korea nuclear problem. For South Korea to first make a suggestion to North Korea and later notify to the US is a violation of the basic principle. We no longer can believe that the ROK and US have “one voice” in policy toward North Korea.
Minister Chung Suggested First Means Assurance of Brethren Cooperation for North Korean Nuclear
It is a dangerous move for our government to make a suggestion to North Korea for inducement to return to the six-party talks without other countries’ consent. The US is demanding for return with no condition. It is worrisome how Washington will respond to South Korea breaking the basic principle after it emphasized a close cooperation between the two countries. There should have been at least an agreement between the two about the suggestion.
It makes us wonder if South Korea has a countermeasure in case the US and other countries do not agree to its “serious sugession.”
The ROK-US summit used to emphasize alliance and cooperation in the negotiation halls but always talked differently once they returned. Minister Chung’s recent remark clearly revealed that our government believes its role to be more important as brethren or North Korea and mediator between the US and North Korea rather than a firm line as an ally of the US for the solution of the North Korean nuclear problem.
Our government has been sending signals of confusion between choosing ally and brethren since the beginning. The recent remark of Minister Chung was actually a determination of our government’s destiny – that it has chose brethren over ally.
President Roh, in his speech on June 13, said the government of preparing for an active supporting suggestion for the North Korea to provide North Korea with economic development and electricity production, ultimately for the abandonment of nuclear. It was actually a statement that showed the framework of the “important suggestion.”
Although we support with our government on providing North Korean regime with security assurance and economic assistance, there are many problem left behind such as HEU problem, subject and extent of nuclear dismantlement, and nuclear inspection methods. How far would North Korea trust the security assurance provided by South Korea without the US’ consent? South Korea focused too much on leading the situation that it ended up playing arrogant.
It would be a mistake to believe that nuclear problem will be resolved soon only because our government sent “few words of gifts” for the brethren cooperation. North Korea’s strategy of trying to use South Korea as its shield is not obvious only to our government.
When the problem is difficult, we must focus more on the principles. ROK-US cooperation is the most secure safety net for the exacerbation of North Korean nuclear problem. Minister Chung’s action was suicidal. Its CVI – “Completely, Verifiable, Irreversible” method made suicidal goal.









