[imText1]A report outlining ways in which China, South Korea and the U.S. might be able to reduce mutual mistrust and suspicion in the process of preparing for and dealing with problems surrounding North Korea has been released by the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a bipartisan think-tank based in Washington, D.C.

The report, “Responding to Change on the Korean Peninsula: Impediments to U.S.-South Korea-China Coordination,” is predicated on the idea that past and present North Korea policy has tended to be “hobbled by impulses towards political, strategic and economic competition” between the three nations which hinders effectiveness.

The report acknowledges that the fundamental aims of all three nations are divergent. China, it notes, is looking for peace, stability, the “maintenance of a non-hostile relationship with its neighbor,” and denuclearization. South Korea, meanwhile, is aiming for peaceful coexistence, dominance during reunification, denuclearization and the maintenance of its alliance with the U.S. come what may; while the U.S. is interested in non-proliferation, but also has to pay attention to both its treaty commitments to South Korea and burgeoning ties with China.

Yet there are similarities in all three positions, and the gaps are far from unbridgeable. Therefore, the report makes a set of recommendations which the authors believe may be able to help the three nations most intimately involved in the North Korea dilemma avoid making mistakes.

It focuses on honesty, by which all parties should try to be clear about what constitutes a situation in which intervention in North Korea would be deemed necessary and what form it would take, for example, while South Korea and the U.S. would commit to not deliberately undermining the existing North Korean government; and clarity, whereby the roles and responsibilities of the three might be raised and quietly codified before any such interventions need to be made.

To these ends, one of the report’s main policy suggestions is that task forces be created by all three governments, to liaise and coordinate on “issues related to North Korean instability.”

In addition, the report calls for a clarification of the future of North Korea’s weapons and weapons programs, namely that all weapons of mass destruction be eliminated in the event of the collapse of the government in Pyongyang, and agreement on the need for coordinated humanitarian efforts under any and all circumstances, regardless of the state of trilateral dialogue on the future shape of North Korea.

In essence, the report notes that while the three countries are destined to have different ambitions regarding North Korea, there is no reason to allow that fact to create a battleground for political, strategic and economic concerns. “The key to building mutual trust,” it concludes, “is for each nation to identify potential common areas of interest regarding the principles and conditions that are needed to promote stability in North Korea and the region.”

“Only if suspicions are assuaged and a modicum of trust is established regarding respective common interests as they relate to North Korea,” it adds, “can all three parties proceed to prepare for North Korean contingencies.”

Chris Green, Leiden University
Christopher Green is a researcher in Korean Studies based at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Chris has published widely on North Korean political messaging strategies, contemporary South Korean broadcast media, and the socio-politics of Korean peninsula migration. He is the former Manager of International Affairs for Daily NK. His X handle is: @Dest_Pyongyang.