President Lee Myung Bak’s visit to China will not only help push forward Sino-South Korean economic cooperation in the form of the mooted ROK-China Free Trade Agreement (FTA), it will also enhance cooperation in diplomatic and security fields, according to some experts.

However, others see the FTA as an economic issue that might be hindered by the presence of political considerations.

Positive thinkers explain that strengthened bilateral economic ties and active communication will make it more difficult for China to be passive or side with North Korea in inter-Korean disputes, but the opposite view has it that China will earn fresh leverage over Korean Peninsula affairs.

It is likely that if working-level negotiations on the FTA begin, everything will accelerate. If the FTA is finally concluded, South Korea and China will have to discuss not only economic matters but about the risk of sudden change caused by instability in and around North Korea.

North Korea not only depends on China economically; China is the only state that continues to maintain a ‘blood alliance’ relationship with the regime in Pyongyang. Therefore, South Korea-China economic ties are bound to affect North Korea in the mid to long term.

Professor Yoon Duk Min of the Institute of Foreign Affairs and National Security told Daily NK, “China is promoting the FTA from a strategic perspective,” adding, “If the ROK-China FTA is concluded it will be likely to influence North Korea in terms of economy and/or politics.”

The late Hwang Jang Yop, a former elite Chosun Workers’ Party secretary, frequently commented of the potential inherent in such an agreement, saying on one occasion, “If an ROK-China Free Trade Agreement is signed then it will offer a good opportunity to separate China and North Korea. It would be a fatal blow for Kim Jong Il.”

Such an FTA would create an invisible economic and political wall around North Korea, it is claimed, isolating them and pushing reform and opening.

China, governed by its realist national interest, would choose to cooperate with South Korea on political issues for the sake of stability, helping to create more unity of purpose on North Korea

However, other analysts see it as making no difference to the overall security environment.

Choi Jin Wook, a senior researcher with the Korea Institute for National Unification commented, “Rather than expecting strengthened diplomatic security it is preferable to approach this as an economic problem.” However, he also added, “In the medium term, if China and South Korea’s relationship becomes closer then there will obviously be a positive effect on North Korea problems.”

“Economic ties between China and South Korea will put great psychological pressure on North Korea. Since it could be a problem for trade negotiations if political issues are raised, it should be approached carefully,” he added.

Kim Il Sung reacted very badly to China establishing diplomatic relations with South Korea in 1992. However, China said that it was a matter of national interest. Something similar would be likely again in this case, with China unlikely to be swayed by Kim Jong Eun’s complaints.