In a piece for Forbes on the 26th, the American Enterprise Institute’s Nicholas Eberstadt questioned whether the international community, notably the U.S., has any real understanding of North Korean motives at all. He wonders whether it is possible to overcome a “seemingly overpowering desire to treat North Korea as the state we would like it to be, rather than as the state it actually is.”

Criticizing what he sees as the apparent blindness of policymakers, Eberstadt points out that there is little chance of successfully dealing with any of the pressing problems that exist with regards to North Korea until “we do them the courtesy of taking them seriously: of understanding what they want from the world, rather than what we think they should want.”

He outlines two key problems; first, that North Korea is “fundamentally committed” to changing the “international chessboard” and the international community doesn’t see it. He claims that North Korea cannot be persuaded to negotiate away its nuclear weapons, if at all, until that international chessboard changes. He focuses on the “American security architecture” that maintains the status quo as North Korea sees it, with that status quo including the ongoing existence of South Korea.

Second, he claims that North Korea does not wish for compromise, viewing it as tantamount to treason, not least because they view the world as an “international life-or-death struggle,” a view Eberstadt regards as not without merit.

Eberstadt singles out U.S. Special Representative Stephen Bosworth for criticism after he claimed that restarting negotiations is in the North Korean long-term interest. It is Eberstadt’s belief that the North Korean interest is best served by a long list of short-term problems which allow it to keep pursuing it’s covert interests, be that missiles or nuclear weapons, indefinitely.

Eberstadt concludes that too often in the past “diplomacy has served as a substitute for strategy,” with uniformly negative results. He claims that until the Obama government creates a real strategy, all that can be expected is further progress in the North Korean nuclear and missile programs.

Chris Green, Leiden University
Christopher Green is a researcher in Korean Studies based at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Chris has published widely on North Korean political messaging strategies, contemporary South Korean broadcast media, and the socio-politics of Korean peninsula migration. He is the former Manager of International Affairs for Daily NK. His X handle is: @Dest_Pyongyang.