In Monday’s New York Times, Professor Andrei Lankov of Kookmin University in Seoul put in writing what most experts believe; that North Korea will definitely not give up their current stock of nuclear weapons.

“It is clear that negotiations with North Korea have no chance to succeed if by “success” one means ‘complete, irreversible and verifiable elimination of North Korea’s nuclear weapons program,’ once postulated by President George W. Bush as the supreme goal of U.S. policy,” Lankov candidly notes in his op-ed piece, “Beating Kim at His Own Game.”

“Only through the existence of the nuclear program can North Korea, a destitute third-rate dictatorship, manipulate the outside world into giving generous aid.”

However, instead of coming to the conclusion that negotiations are futile, Professor Lankov puts forward a different set of aspirations which he believes makes them worthwhile; first of all, the possibility of agreement on “dismantling the North Korean nuclear research and production facilities” and “some nonproliferation measures;” and, secondly, the additional benefit of keeping some avenues of communication open between Pyongyang and the outside world.

Since North Korea’s current stocks of nuclear weapons are more than enough for both deterrence and “diplomatic blackmail,” Lankov reasons that, for a price of course, Pyongyang might be willing to dismantle the research facilities that made them possible in the first place.

The benefits of so doing, especially in terms of non-proliferation overseas, would make it a price potentially worth paying.

In addition, maintaining communications between the North and the outside world could be important at any future time of crisis, while all methods of getting information to flow into North Korea are to be encouraged, Lankov reasons, for their capacity to undermine a regime whose “legitimacy is largely based on false claims.”

But regardless of the aim, Lankov is quick to counsel caution, and makes it clear that nobody should expect too much. Reminding readers that North Korea tends towards “histrionics,” he encourages calm and polite indifference, while noting that the U.S. should prepare for and absolutely not submit to the distinct possibility that North Korea will “use their favorite trick and stage yet another crisis in order to demand more money for restoring the status quo.”

Chris Green, Leiden University
Christopher Green is a researcher in Korean Studies based at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Chris has published widely on North Korean political messaging strategies, contemporary South Korean broadcast media, and the socio-politics of Korean peninsula migration. He is the former Manager of International Affairs for Daily NK. His X handle is: @Dest_Pyongyang.