Recent Chinese aid to North Korea is “undoubtedly” in violation of UN Resolution 1874, and the U.S. should not brush it under the carpet, says a prominent conservative North Korea expert.

Gordon Chang, the author of “Nuclear Showdown: North Korea Takes on the World,” argued in an opinion piece for Thursday’s Wall Street Journal that the package of commercial deals struck by Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao and Kim Jong Il last week clearly violate the Resolution and are likely to strengthen North Korea’s economy, which will indirectly allow Pyongyang to keep it’s weapons programs. Such clear violations of UN resolutions should not be allowed to go unpunished, Chang asserts.

Paragraph 19 of Resolution 1874 calls on UN member states “not to enter into new commitments for grants, financial assistance, or concessional loans to the DPRK, except for humanitarian and developmental purposes directly addressing the needs of the civilian population, or the promotion of denuclearization,” while Paragraph 20 asks them “not to provide public financial support for trade with the DPRK… where such financial support could contribute to the DPRK’s nuclear-related or ballistic missile-related or other WMD-related programs or activities.”

Conceding that the aid might be conditional upon a return to multilateral talks, Chang nevertheless argues that as the provider of “90% of North Korea’s oil, 80% of its consumer goods and 45% of its food,” China could be using its influence over its neighbor better than it currently is, and that there is little chance of the aid not violating Resolution 1874 one way or another.

The only part of the aid package which has been publicly revealed to date is that of a new bridge over the Yalu River, which the Chinese hope will eventually form part of a Busan-Seoul-Pyongyang-Beijing international trade route. Questions have not been raised as to whether this is in violation of Resolution 1874; since the Kaesong Industrial Complex is determined not to be, a bridge which was planned two years ago, thus pre-dating Resolution 1874, probably isn’t either.

Regardless, the U.S. should at least match the response of South Korea by demanding an explanation of “the precise nature of its economic relations with the sanctioned Pyongyang regime,” according to Chang.

Washington has made no comment on the issue to date, with the State Department remaining firmly on the subject of multilateral talks in last Wednesday’s press briefing, shortly after Premier Wen returned to Beijing. “I’m not going to get into the details of it,” said spokesperson Ian Kelly, “I will say that we told the Chinese that we welcome their efforts to convince the North Koreans to return to Six-Party Talks.”

In conclusion, Chang points out that the U.S. and the UN ought not to tolerate China’s support for its neighbor when that support brings it into conflict with an existing resolution, for, “There is no point in working through the U.N. if permanent Security Council members are allowed to violate its resolutions.”

Chris Green, Leiden University
Christopher Green is a researcher in Korean Studies based at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Chris has published widely on North Korean political messaging strategies, contemporary South Korean broadcast media, and the socio-politics of Korean peninsula migration. He is the former Manager of International Affairs for Daily NK. His X handle is: @Dest_Pyongyang.