North Korean workers favor positions in the state bureaucracy because they provide “a platform for engaging in business or corrupt or criminal rent extraction,” according to a recent working paper from economic policy research organization the Peterson Institute, corruption which another new report from the East-West Center concludes is being exacerbated by fear of incarceration in one of North Korea’s prison camps.

The first report, “Reform from Below: Behavioral and Institutional Change in North Korea” by Marcus Noland and Stephen Haggard uses recent and past responses of North Korean refugees to questions about their perceptions of the North Korean economy to assess the process of “marketization from below” that is characteristic of the market system in North Korea.

The paper asserts that while the post-2002 period marked an improvement in the degree of legal access to markets for civilians, thereafter the basic market situation for traders both large and small hasn’t changed a great deal, with constant and disruptive changes to market regulations and the need for bribery being constant features of doing business.

In the most recent survey conducted for the paper, 85% of respondents reported the need to give bribes to do business, while less than 50% believe that it has become easier to engage in private trading.

Additionally, upon being asked what the best way to get ahead in North Korea is, a huge majority of people showed a preference for entering the government or Party bureaucracy, a fact which has not changed much since the famine period. Since respondents also believe that the best way to make money in North Korea is to engage in market, corrupt or criminal activities, it can be assumed that a job in the government or Party bureaucracy is desirable primarily because it provides the holder with access to the market and, in the role of gatekeeper, both corrupt and criminal activities such as bribe-taking.

Indeed, among respondents who worked in the government or Party bureaucracy, more than 80% said that government and Party officials had become more corrupt.

Needless to say, therefore, that working hard at one’s assigned job is seen as neither a good way to get ahead nor a good way to get rich.

In the second new report, the same authors also reveal how research suggests that a brief but painful stop in a North Korean prison camp for those found guilty of breaking arbitrary and counter-intuitive market regulations is a way of maintaining a high degree of fear among the population, which the report points out is good for the regime, but is an encouragement to bribe officials in order to avoid incarceration which is exacerbating the already high degree of corruption inherent in the North Korean economy.

As Noland, who spoke to the Washington Post about the report, “Repression and Punishment in North Korea,” put it, the North Korean system “really looks like the work of a gang, a kind of ‘Soprano’ state. But it succeeds in keeping people repressed.”

After all, as the report concludes, “The more arbitrary and painful the experience with the penal system, the easier it is for officials to extort money for avoiding it.”

Regardless of the manifest failings inherent in North Korean marketization, however, in comparing the situation in North Korea’s northern provinces with the areas of China worst hit by the Great Leap Forward of the late 1950s, the Peterson Institute paper is able to suggest a positive aspect: that the robustness of the market in hard hit places may have been helped by the catastrophic conditions out of which it grew, allowing those regions to position themselves as future growth centers.

Chris Green, Leiden University
Christopher Green is a researcher in Korean Studies based at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Chris has published widely on North Korean political messaging strategies, contemporary South Korean broadcast media, and the socio-politics of Korean peninsula migration. He is the former Manager of International Affairs for Daily NK. His X handle is: @Dest_Pyongyang.