[imText1]Lord Alton, a member of the British House of Lords and chair of the British-North Korea All Party Parliamentary Group, has told The Daily NK in a new interview the reasons behind the recent visit to the UK of Supreme People’s Assembly speaker Choi Tae Bok, and explained why he believes two notable successes in the pursuit of peaceful political change involving the British government, Northern Ireland and Hong Kong, have something to offer future efforts to transform the political landscape on the Korean Peninsula,
“Who could ever forget the day that the Reverend Ian Paisley became First Minister of Northern Ireland, and Martin McGuinness, who had been his life-long enemy and foe, became his deputy minister?” Lord Alton points out in the interview, which was held at the Houses of Parliament in London.
“Every situation is different, but are there lessons we could learn? Yes, there are,” he goes on, adding, “There are many characteristics that people in the north of Ireland share whether unionist or republican, but the problem was getting them to sit down and actually talk to one another.”
Under the Northern Ireland peace process, terrorists from both unionist and loyalist factions laid down their arms in the late 1990s and entered a peaceful political process under Senator George Mitchell, a process which led to the Good Friday Agreement and a peace which has largely held to this day.
“I particularly wanted to emphasize the idea of a new initiative using outside facilitators and bringing together North and South,” Lord Alton explains, noting that he introduced Choi to a range of figures from Northern Ireland during the visit, including two former speakers of the Northern Ireland Assembly and a current Minister of State for Northern Ireland, Hugo Swire.
“I also brought two former terrorists, both of whom have done time for crimes of violence, one from the IRA, one from the UDF, both of whom have renounced violence and become part of the political process, been involved in the healing and reconciliation that has so transformed the situation in Northern Ireland,” he continues.
Discussing the visit of Choi, which attracted attention mostly for the inclusion of some of the most prominent of North Korea’s recent calls for food aid, Lord Alton says the North Korean showed a particular interest in the handover of Hong Kong to Chinese rule in 1997. It may, he notes, have been the fact that negotiations in that case were held between the British government and Pyongyang’s closest ally that made the case more intriguing.
“I introduced him to Geoffrey Howe, our former deputy prime minister, and they had a very good session on two systems in one country. I think (the North Korean delegation) were quite taken with meeting someone who had been in direct negotiations with the Chinese leadership and who had been able to bring about a peaceful transition, one which has born incredible fruits in the country that is adjacent to North Korea,” he adds.
In addition, Lord Alton explains other parts of Choi’s visit, including the story of a tense meeting with a North Korean defector, Kim Joo Il, during a parliamentary meeting at the Houses of Parliament, a trip to the School of Oriental and Asian Studies and a leading TB treatment unit, but also a number of cultural events including a show in the West End, revealing too that Choi harbors an interest in the poetry of Lord Byron.
Ultimately, Lord Alton, who hopes to see the launch of a literary festival in Pyongyang sometime next year, says that he believes no matter how intractable the Korean Peninsula problem may appear, by keeping lines of communication open and showing how cases including Northern Ireland and Hong Kong have been resolved, the situation on the Korean Peninsula can also be resolved peacefully.
“With the right kind of long-term strategy, what I have described as Helsinki but with a Korean face, I think you could bring this to a successful conclusion,” he says.
Below is a transcript of part of the interview with Lord Alton;
– How did you get involved with North Korean issues originally?
About eight years ago a colleague of mine, Lady Cox, was out of London and her office rang me to say that she’d been due to meet a North Korean defector who had come to London and in her absence would I be willing to meet him. So I said, “But I don’t know anything about North Korea!” and the chap in her office said, “Well no-one knows much about North Korea so that’s not much of an excuse!” We both laughed and I said I’d see him.
I was very moved by his story; his wife and two children had died in the famine of the 1990s and his other son had been lost as he tried to escape from the country over the Yalu River, their other son also died on his route out.
But as he told me his story I felt a certain inadequacy; I’m not foreign secretary, I’m not a member of the government… but I did serve eighteen years in the House of Commons, so the one thing I do know a little bit about is parliament and how you can perhaps tell a story there, so I did promise him that I would try to raise his own case, tell the story and try to discover a little more about human rights questions in North Korea. That’s how my interest began.
Thereafter, I put down a motion for debate, the motion came up about a month later and, conveniently, between my putting down the motion and the debate taking place the North Koreans reactivated the reactor at Yongbyon; so a small debate became quite a big one, and since I had entitled the debate ‘Human Rights and Security Questions on the Korean Peninsula’, there was quite a lot of parliamentary interest.
The BBC covered that debate, and I got a call from the then-North Korean ambassador in London… he suggested that maybe I had been listening to too many Americans in my remarks, so I told him I hadn’t spoken to any.
– He rebuffed you, directly?
Well, he said he disagreed with what I had said, so I suggested that he come in and talk about it, which he did; we had a cup of coffee and agreed to disagree about the substance of my remarks.
But I made the point that they never allowed anyone into the country anyway, so how would I be able to verify what I had been told one way or the other, and he then asked me directly, “Would you be willing to go?” Well I didn’t say, “But would I come back?” although the thought did cross my mind, instead I said yes I’d be willing to go, so I rang Lady Cox and said, “Look, this is all your fault because you weren’t here, how would you fancy a visit to North Korea?”
We paid our own way, we had a clear agreement with them in advance that we would be able to raise human rights issues, we said we would publish a report at the end of it, we said that if they tried to use our visit for any kind of propaganda or ideological purposes we would disassociate ourselves from it so it would be of no value to them anyway, and they played it entirely straight, sufficiently so that Lady Cox and I decided it might be worth trying to establish an all-party parliamentary group.
Next we invited speaker Choi Tae Bok, who we had met on that first visit, to come here, we had a second visit, and then he came again two weeks ago. We have described this as constructive but critical engagement; obviously we are not fellow travelers, I am not an appeaser and I don’t hold out any apologia for the North Korean regime in any respect, but I do think there is a time for every moment under heaven; there is a time to engage and to keep open lines of communication and dialogue.
– Have you seen any notable success, in your opinion?
The fact that we can have the discussions and that no-one tries to prevent us from raising the issues is itself significant. And there are little successes, for instance I think the entrenchment of the English language in North Korea is of great long-term importance; it’s now eight or nine years since the British Council first sent its English teachers, and there is usually a team of four teachers both in Kim Il Sung University and in schools that I have visited. It is clear to me that English is being taught to a high standard. The new Pyongyang Higher Institute of Science and Technology would also have been unimaginable even five years ago, but there it is.
– It finally opened its doors, I recall.
It did, and we visited it during our last visit. It has faculty from North America and Western Europe, teaching all its students in English. English is now the second language of North Korea, which is an extraordinary breakthrough.
I was very heavily involved during the 1980s in what was very loosely called the Helsinki Process, and believe strongly that the Helsinki Process of linking security and human rights questions was the right way to bring about change. But it had to be painstaking; I was a great believer that through education, through language teaching, direct personal contact and communication you could bring about some kind of small change. And then in 1989…
– Wasn’t a small change, was it!
Long before we anticipated it we saw a very big change!
So I can’t answer your question directly; I don’t know how much good or harm these things do, but we raise individual cases, we always leave reports with them; last time I took all the reports of the UN Special Rapporteur who was never allowed into the country, we presented them to foreign ministers, to the speaker. We raised all the kinds of issues that you would anticipate we would raise, and if no-one goes and asks those questions why would they even have them on their agenda?
– When Choi Tae Bok came here this year, what specifically were you aiming to achieve?
I wanted to expose him to the way we build our civil society in Britain, and I particularly wanted to expose him and his delegation to the Northern Ireland peace process. During my time in the House of Commons I was the Liberal Party spokesperson on Northern Ireland in the genesis of the Northern Ireland peace process and I traveled there many times, so I was able to bring to a meeting with Choi Tae Bok two former speakers of the Northern Ireland Assembly, one significantly a woman, Eileen Bell, and John Alderdice, now Lord Alderdice, who spoke a lot about the building blocks that you need to put in place to be able to begin a peace process.
I also brought the Northern Ireland minister, Hugo Swire, who spoke about where we have got to today as a result of the Good Friday Agreement, and I brought two former terrorists, both of whom have done time for crimes of violence, one from the IRA, one from the UDF, both of whom have renounced violence and become part of the political process, been involved in the healing and reconciliation that has so transformed the situation in Northern Ireland.
It’s not all over yet, but it is much improved compared with where we were, 3,000 people died in the troubles in Northern Ireland, 20,000 were injured, hundreds of thousands if not millions of pounds of damage was done during that period to the economy of both Northern Ireland and targets on the mainland as well.
I also introduced him to Geoffrey Howe, our former deputy prime minister, and they had a very good session on two systems in one country, he talked about how he had negotiated directly with the Chinese over the Hong Kong agreement, and I think they were quite taken with meeting someone who had been in direct negotiations with the Chinese leadership and who had been able to bring about a peaceful transition, one which has born incredible fruits in the country that is adjacent to North Korea.
I think he was very interested in how the negotiations with Deng Xiaoping had taken place, how the negotiations in Northern Ireland had taken place; I particularly wanted to emphasize the idea of a new initiative using outside facilitators and bringing together North and South. I think we need a new peace treaty; I think the armistice is very shaky and the sinking of the Cheonan is an example of that. There is not outright war, but there is no peace either, so something has to replace the armistice. I think Tony Blair made the right decision when he overruled his then foreign secretary, Robin Cook, and unilaterally decided that the war was over and that we could form diplomatic relations with North Korea; it doesn’t mean we approve of their regime or ideology but it does mean we have a presence and it gives us a chance to try and influence events.
You see, I believe this is a soluble problem. I’ve visited some of the hotspots in the Middle East, some of the more difficult, more intractable problems in the world, and in comparison I think this is a soluble problem that with the right kind of long-term strategy, what I have described as Helsinki but with a Korean face, I think you could bring this to a successful conclusion.
– But there have been deals before, behind which North Korea continued to develop its nuclear weapons, for example.
There has been duplicity, of that there is no doubt, but North Korea is also staring some harsh realities in the face; 2 million people died in the famine in the 1990s, the World Food Programme has just reported on increases in malnutrition and the failure of last year’s crops, the harshest winter in 60 years, and during Choi Tae Bok’s visit to London the repeated requests for the international community and NGO’s to respond to the food crisis. So this is a country that knows it needs to change if there is to be any possibility of prosperity in the future. They emphasized the need for two things before 2012; they wanted to see prosperity and human dignity, and that second one was a phrase I had not heard before.
– Those were their words?
That was the translation we were given.
You can’t assume that everybody in North Korea thinks the same; I think people live in silos and have very different views, i.e. no doubt those in the military have different views from those in the political classes, and people may be at different points in the curve, so the important thing is to try to draw everyone into the same place, something which requires a lot of intelligent effort. I think the past deals that you referred to were just attempts to paper over cracks; I don’t think they were long-term strategies.
I think you need to put all the cards on the table at once, not just a deal on energy or a deal on trade, a specific initiative on a joint area for enhancing prosperity or whatever the initiative may be. All these are useful small things, but there needs to be a comprehensive package. I think you have to almost take North Korea at its word, and test their sincerity. The situation couldn’t become much worse, that’s for sure.
– The North has often said that it pursues unification under its own system…
That is not what they’ve said in discussion with me, where they’ve said that their system could not be imposed on the South, which would be unacceptable to the South, to the international community…. Hence why the Northern Ireland model or two systems in one country, and the Hong Kong model; when you look at China, it is the Hong Kong model that has won all the battles, so if you go to Beijing or Shanghai today, they are far more like Hong Kong than Pyongyang!
– So you think the Northern Ireland situation could play a genuine role?
Yes, I do. I think there are differences; there is homogeneity about Korea which you could say isn’t present in Ireland, although 40% of the population of Ireland comes from a nationalist tradition, so there is homogeneity with the rest of Ireland, the 60% of course from a unionist, loyalist tradition, and see themselves as British.
On the other hand, there are many characteristics that people in the north of Ireland share, whether unionist or republican, and the problem was getting them to actually sit down and talk to one another. Who could ever forget the day that the Reverend Ian Paisley became First Minister of Northern Ireland, and Martin McGuinness, who had been his life-long enemy and foe, became his deputy minister?
So are there parallels here? Well every situation is different, but are there lessons we could learn? Yes, there are, and I think the Hong Kong experience as well, in terms of painstaking negotiation and sorting out the guarantees that were necessary to ensure that Hong Kong would be able to keep its prosperity, its political system, its liberties, particularly its religious freedoms, something greatly prized in South Korea as well, all those would have to be in place, and are already in place in South Korea, and will remain in place.
– I believe Choi also met a North Korean defector at one point.
Yes, in fact he was brought to the meeting with Choi Tae Bok by Greg Hands, the Conservative MP for Westminster and Fulham; he made the point that if North Korea disputes the existence of prison camps why is it that people like (defector Kim Joo Il) are here to tell us about their own experiences.
– And did Kim then proceed to do so?
Well it was a meeting for parliamentarians; he was brought as evidence rather than as a witness, but Mr. Hands and some of the other members of parliament who were present gave examples of people who have seen their human rights abused in North Korea. The UN estimates that there are some 300,000 people in the camps in North Korea, it is a figure we used during our discussions. I use the phrase constructive but critical engagement; there is no point pretending that we approve of the regime or some of the things it has been responsible for, and it is important that they know that we know.
– How did Choi react to that?
He was very measured; he didn’t want to receive any documents from the defector who was there, but he stayed at the meeting. It was a tense moment, there was a tense exchange. But he recalled that on a previous occasion I had given him copies of a BBC ‘Panorama’ program where they interviewed people who had said they had chemical weapons tested on them in North Korean prison camps, so he would have been very surprised if we hadn’t raised these questions. I think it is an example of the value of creating a relationship over a long period of time. That wouldn’t have been possible seven years ago, it was possible this time, and I made it perfectly clear that it was the right of an MP to put forward his point of view in a free parliament and a democracy, and that it would be phony if such an exchange weren’t able to take place. So it passed off without further comment.
– Do you think this information will carry weight back in Pyongyang? Do you think that information could actually make an impact?
Everything that is said and everything that happens is carefully recorded, taken back and disseminated. Nothing that happened won’t have been recorded; there were tense moments and there were positive moments as well. They went for instance to SOAS, the School of Oriental and African Studies, and the possibility has been held out to them of educational exchanges, something that they would very much like, but all that is predicated on political progress. They went to Queen Mary’s Hospital to see our TB unit; I went to a unit in Pyongyang; TB is a major killer in North Korea. Queen Mary’s Hospital is a state of the art, cutting edge hospital and one would like to see a full-blooded relationship developing but that would be difficult again without proper political progress being made.
We also emphasized the role that religious pluralism plays in the life of the nation; we went to Westminster Abbey and showed them around. Choi Tae Bok also has a great interest in Lord Byron and his poetry, so we presented him with a 19th Century edition of Byron’s collected works and took him to Poet’s Corner in Westminster Abbey and had quite an interesting conversation about that. So it isn’t impossible to find things about which to at least converse, and open up possibilities of raising some things which are more controversial.
We also took them to see Warhorse, which is about to be made into a movie and is just opening on Broadway; it tells of the terrible suffering during the First World War. We also made sure they had congenial discussions with people while they were here, that they were treated with some respect; they met both the speakers of the House of Lords and House of Commons, but again during those discussions human rights issues were the key, the building of democratic, plural societies and what that would mean, and what possibilities that would raise for North Korea if it moved in that direction. All of this will have been relayed back I am certain, and I hope it is possible to keep building on those.
I mentioned English earlier, well one thing we hope to bring about next year in Pyongyang under the patronage of Choi Tae Bok is a Pyongyang Literary Festival to celebrate English literature. This doesn’t aid and abet militarism in any way but it does help education and it does help to extend the reach of the English language with a celebration of something that is precious to us and is becoming increasingly precious to them. So we hope it is possible to bring that about.










