“Political crimes are the main enemy.
Do not work with a conscience.
Kill anyone who resists.
Always travel in teams of three and carry a loaded gun.
Fraternizing with prisoners is forbidden.”

“Admit your mistakes and regret them profoundly.
Pledge unquestioning obedience.
Theft, sexual relations and gathering in groups are forbidden.
Immediately report any unauthorized persons.
Do your work well.”

The first is the code of conduct for prison guards. Below it, the code of conduct for prisoners. At least 130,000 (150,000 by National Intelligence Service estimates) people in six different camps; 14 (Kaecheon), 15 (Yoduk), 16 (Hwasung), 18 (Bukchang), 22 (Hoiryeong) and 25 (Chongjin), live in this world, one where no one has never heard the phrase ‘human rights’.

On Thursday, the Database Center for North Korean Human Rights held a seminar to coincide with the publication of a thousand-page document of interviews with 13,000 defectors, condemning the human rights situation within North Korea’s political prisons and detention facilities.

It is not only an issue within political prisons and camps, of course. There are also between 180 and nearly 500 basic detention facilities within North Korea, including detention houses, processing facilities, labor internment camps, reformatories and re-education camps. Some observers claim that as many as 250,000 people are being detained at these facilities. The fact that prisoners lose their identification cards when they enter a facility such as this symbolizes the fact that they are no longer to be treated as human beings.

In 1974, Kim Jong Il created the Party’s Ten Principles for the Establishment of the One-Ideology System, which solidified Kim Il Sung’s authority and defined the kind of dictatorship North Korea would become. Under it, Kim Jong Il, and now son Jong Eun, too, treat the nation’s 23 million people as slaves. At least in that sense, North Korean society itself is little more than a prison.

Declaring that South Korea will no longer ignore these human rights violations is surely the core purpose of the proposed North Korea Human Rights Act.

However, opponents suggest, as one academic advocate said at a recent debate, “The only policy option is the development of North-South relations through inter-Korean exchanges and aid and an awakening of the North Korean citizenry.”

Yet it is well-known that aid given to North Korea over the last ten years has meant life support for a Kim Jong Il administration nearing disintegration. Claiming that inter-Korean exchanges and aid are the only policy alternative can only reinforce the idea that the stability of the regime has to come before the lives of the North Korean people.

Let us be clear. The cruel reality contained within the pages of this thousand-page report about North Korea’s detention facilities is that increased inter-Korean exchanges are not going to change anything. Such critical issues can only be resolved when the North Korean regime goes from being one that systematically violates the human rights of its own people to one that rules in their interests.

While it is fair and reasonable that there should be differences between the positions of progressives and the conservatives on North Korea, it is surely unacceptable for either side to ignore the human rights situation in North Korea in the hope of some kind of progress in the relationship between North and South.

The main reason why left-wing figures are coming out in opposition to the proposed North Korean Human Rights Act is because the resolution of human rights issues in North Korea is inextricably linked to the removal of the Kim Jong Il regime.

Daily NK
Questions or comments about this article? Contact us at dailynkenglish@uni-media.net.